Murder & Manslaughter

Introduction: Why Expert Legal Advice is Non-Negotiable

If you or someone you know is facing charges related to unlawful killing, the situation is dire and the stakes are high. Immediate consultation with our team of expert criminal lawyers is not just advisable—it’s essential. This comprehensive guide aims to provide a detailed overview of the various offences and legal intricacies involved. Please contact us here

Delving Deep into Murder Charges

What Exactly is Murder in Victoria?

In Victoria, murder is not defined by legislation but is a common law offence. This means that its elements are shaped by judicial decisions over time. However, the Crimes Act does specify that anyone found guilty of murder faces a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. Cases of this magnitude are exclusively heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

Four Pillars of a Murder Conviction

To secure a murder conviction, the prosecution must irrefutably prove the following:
  • The accused directly caused the victim’s death.
  • The actions leading to the death were conscious, voluntary, and deliberate.
  • The accused had the intent to kill or cause serious injury, fully aware that such outcomes were likely.
  • There was no lawful justification for the act, such as self-defence.

Reckless Murder: A Special Category

If the accused did not intend to cause harm but knew that their actions were likely to result in serious injury or death, they could still be convicted of what is known as ‘reckless murder.’

Defences Against Murder Charges

Depending on the specifics of your case, several defences may be available. Our experienced criminal defence lawyers can assess your situation and may argue for defences like self-defence, duress, sudden and extraordinary emergency, or even automatism.

Attempted Murder: An Act Cut Short

In Victoria, attempted murder is considered an ‘inchoate’ offence, meaning it’s incomplete. To convict someone of attempted murder, the prosecution must prove two key elements:
  • The accused had a clear intent to commit murder.
  • The accused took substantial steps toward committing the act.

Constructive or Statutory Murder 3A: Unintended Consequences

If you unintentionally cause someone’s death while committing another violent crime, you could be charged with constructive murder. The associated violent crime must carry a maximum penalty of at least 10 years imprisonment. The legal foundation for constructive murder in Victoria lies in the Crimes Act. Specifically, you’ll find the relevant provisions under Section 3A of the Act.

Key Elements for Conviction

To secure a conviction for constructive murder, the prosecution must prove that:
  • The accused unintentionally killed someone.
  • The killing occurred during the commission of a violent crime.
  • The associated violent crime carries a maximum penalty of at least 10 years imprisonment.

Infanticide: A Sensitive and Complex Offence

Infanticide applies to women who kill their child but were suffering from a mental disturbance caused by not having fully recovered from childbirth. The maximum penalty for infanticide is five years imprisonment.

Voluntary Manslaughter: When Murder is Mitigated

Defining Voluntary Manslaughter

Voluntary manslaughter is an intentional killing that occurs under mitigating circumstances, such as extreme emotional disturbance. The maximum penalty is 25 years imprisonment.

How It Differs from Murder

The key difference lies in the presence of mitigating factors that reduce the moral culpability of the accused. While the act is intentional, it is often less premeditated than murder and may involve elements of provocation.

Involuntary Manslaughter: The Accidental Killer

Types and Elements

Involuntary manslaughter can occur in two main forms:
  1. Manslaughter by Criminal Negligence: Here, the accused had a duty of care toward the victim and breached that duty, leading to the victim’s death.
  2. Manslaughter by Unlawful Dangerous Act: In this case, the accused committed an unlawful act that was dangerous and led to the victim’s death.

Other Offences in the Manslaughter Category

Workplace Manslaughter: Safety First

This is a recent addition to Victoria’s legal landscape, targeting negligent acts in the workplace that result in death. Penalties can be as severe as 25 years imprisonment for individuals and significant fines for corporate bodies.

The One Punch Law: A Fatal Strike

This law applies when a single punch or strike to the head or neck leads to death. The maximum penalty is 25 years imprisonment.

Suicide Pacts: A Tragic Agreement

If you survive a suicide pact but the other person dies, you could be charged with manslaughter, not murder. The maximum penalty is 10 years imprisonment.

Conclusion: Legal Expertise is Your Best Ally

Given the complexity and severity of these charges, securing expert legal advice is not just an option—it’s a necessity. Contact our team for a consultation tailored to your unique circumstances.

Further Reading:

Homicide in Victoria: Offenders, Victims and Sentencing Homicide – Victims of Crime

Book a free 30 min consultation

Need to discuss a case? Get in touch for a free and confidential chat.