Supreme Court Bail Application Lawyer Victoria


Supreme Court bail application lawyer Victoria

Need a Supreme Court bail application for someone on remand? Call 0493 710 531. We answer seven days, and we start on bail material straight away.

When the Magistrates’ Court refuses bail, or the charge is murder, the next step is often a Supreme Court bail application. These applications are serious undertakings. A judge will expect detailed evidence, a workable plan and an answer to every risk the prosecution raises. This page explains how Supreme Court bail works in Victoria under the current law.

McMahon Criminal Defence Lawyers prepares and runs bail applications in the Magistrates’, County and Supreme Courts. We act for private clients in indictable matters, and we work with experienced counsel where the case calls for it.

When Do You Need a Supreme Court Bail Application?

  • Murder or treason. Only the Supreme Court can grant bail for treason. For murder, only the Supreme Court can grant bail, unless a court does so on committing the person for trial (Bail Act 1977 s 13(1)–(2)).
  • Bail refused in the Magistrates’ Court. The Act restricts further applications in the same court. Generally, after the first two applications, you need new facts or circumstances (s 18AA(1)). However, that limit does not take away the right to apply to the Supreme Court (s 18AA(2)).
  • Serious matters needing a judge. In complex or high-stakes cases, a carefully prepared Supreme Court application may give the best prospect of release.

Note also that only a court, not police or a bail justice, can grant bail for a Schedule 1 offence (s 13(3)).

The Tests for Supreme Court Bail

Victorian bail law uses a two-step process for serious charges. First, the accused may have to show exceptional circumstances or a compelling reason. Then, the court asks whether there is an unacceptable risk.

Step Applies to Who must prove it Law
Exceptional circumstances Schedule 1 offences, such as murder, armed robbery, aggravated burglary, home invasion, carjacking and commercial drug trafficking. It also applies to some Schedule 2 offences, for example if allegedly committed while on bail for another Schedule 1 or 2 offence The accused ss 4AA(1)–(2), 4A
Compelling reason Schedule 2 offences, such as many serious sexual and violent offences and trafficking. Since 2025, it also applies to an indictable offence allegedly committed while on bail, where a section 30B charge is laid The accused ss 4AA(3)–(4A), 4C
Unacceptable risk Every bail decision The prosecution ss 4D, 4E

Under the final step, the court must refuse bail if there is an unacceptable risk that the accused would:

  • commit a Schedule 1 or Schedule 2 offence;
  • otherwise endanger the safety or welfare of any person;
  • interfere with a witness or obstruct justice; or
  • fail to appear at court (s 4E(1)).

Importantly, the court must consider whether bail conditions can reduce a risk so that it is no longer unacceptable (s 4E(3)(b)). As a result, a strong bail plan often decides the outcome.

What the Court Considers

At each step, the court must take into account the “surrounding circumstances” (s 3AAA). These include:

  • the nature and seriousness of the alleged offending;
  • the strength of the prosecution case;
  • your criminal history, and how you complied with any earlier bail;
  • whether you were on bail, parole or a community correction order at the time;
  • any family violence intervention order or safety notice against you;
  • your personal circumstances, including caring responsibilities, associations and home environment;
  • any special vulnerability;
  • the availability of treatment or bail support services;
  • the known or likely views of any alleged victim;
  • how long you are likely to spend in custody if bail is refused, and the likely sentence; and
  • whether time on remand would likely exceed any prison sentence you might receive.

The court must also consider additional matters for Aboriginal people and children (ss 3A, 3B).

The 2025 Bail Changes

Victoria’s bail laws changed significantly in 2025. In summary:

  • Community safety first. Parliament now recognises the overarching importance of maximising community safety (s 1B(1AA)).
  • More Schedule 1 offences. Armed robbery, aggravated burglary, home invasion and carjacking now sit in Schedule 1. Consequently, the exceptional circumstances test applies.
  • Offending on bail. Committing an indictable offence while on bail is again an offence, carrying up to 3 months’ imprisonment or 30 penalty units (s 30B). It can also trigger the compelling reason test (s 4AA(4A)).
  • Repeat serious offending. This covers offences such as armed robbery and home invasion allegedly committed while on bail for one of them. There, the risk of further serious offending is unacceptable unless the court finds a high degree of probability that the accused would not commit another of those offences (s 4F).

Older guidance online may not reflect these changes. Therefore, check the date of anything you read.

How We Prepare a Supreme Court Bail Application

A Supreme Court bail application is a fresh hearing, so preparation is everything. Typically, we:

  1. Analyse the prosecution case for weaknesses, since strength of the case is a key factor.
  2. Build the bail plan. This covers stable accommodation away from complainants and co-accused, plus work, study or treatment commitments.
  3. Propose conditions that answer each risk, such as reporting, curfews, residence requirements and no-contact conditions.
  4. Arrange support, such as a bail guarantor (surety), treatment providers or a bail support service.
  5. Prepare evidence, usually sworn affidavits from the accused’s family, employers and treating professionals.
  6. Brief counsel where appropriate, and run the hearing.

Bail decisions are rarely second chances. A rushed application that fails can make the next one harder, so start with a properly prepared one.

If Bail Is Refused

Refusal is not always the end. A further application may be possible if new facts or circumstances arise, for instance a new treatment place or a change in the prosecution case (s 18AA). In the meantime, time held in custody is generally deducted from any sentence (Sentencing Act 1991 s 18).

See also our main bail page, our page on drug trafficking, and our page on murder and manslaughter.

Why Clients Choose Us

  • Trial experience in the County Court and Supreme Court, in Ballarat and in Melbourne.
  • Fixed fees by stage, so you know the cost of each step in a serious matter. See our fees.
  • Complete discretion. We understand what a criminal investigation means for professionals and business owners.
  • Available when it happens. Arrests and raids rarely happen in office hours, so we answer early mornings and weekends.

Read the legislation: Bail Act 1977 (Vic).

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I apply to the Supreme Court if the Magistrates’ Court refused bail?

Yes. The Bail Act limits repeat applications in the Magistrates’ Court, but it expressly preserves the right of a person in custody to apply to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court hears the application afresh.

Who can grant bail on a murder charge in Victoria?

Only the Supreme Court, unless a court grants bail when committing the person for trial. Murder is also a Schedule 1 offence, so the accused must show exceptional circumstances.

What are exceptional circumstances for bail?

The Act does not define them. The court looks at all the surrounding circumstances, including the strength of the prosecution case, the likely sentence, the likely time on remand, and personal factors. The accused bears the burden of establishing them.

Do I need a surety for Supreme Court bail?

Not always. A bail guarantor can strengthen an application, but the court can grant bail without one. What matters is whether the overall plan answers the risks.

How did the 2025 bail changes affect Supreme Court applications?

They made bail harder for several offences. Armed robbery, aggravated burglary, home invasion and carjacking moved into Schedule 1, offending on bail became an offence again, and community safety became the overarching consideration.

Does time on remand count towards a sentence?

Generally, yes. Under section 18 of the Sentencing Act 1991, time held in custody before trial is generally deducted from a prison sentence for the offence.



Someone You Love on Remand? Act Now.

Call 0493 710 531. We prepare Supreme Court bail applications properly, from the bail plan to the affidavits.

Get in Touch

Contact us for a confidential consultation with an experienced criminal defence lawyer.

Name
Email
How would you like to discuss your case?
Drag & Drop Files, Choose Files to Upload You can upload up to 10 files.