Police at your door with a search warrant right now? Call 0493 710 531. We answer seven days, including early mornings.
A search warrant usually arrives without warning, often at dawn. However, what you say and do in the next few hours can shape the entire case. This page explains search warrant law in Victoria. It also covers your rights during a police raid, and what happens next.
McMahon Criminal Defence Lawyers acts for private clients in serious criminal matters. We run trials in Ballarat and Melbourne, in both the County Court and the Supreme Court. For indictable matters, we act for private clients only, not on Legal Aid.
What to Do When Police Arrive With a Search Warrant
- Stay calm and do not obstruct the search. A valid warrant allows police to enter, by force if necessary. Moreover, obstructing police is a separate offence. See our page on resisting or obstructing police.
- Ask to see the warrant. Read it carefully. Note the address, the offence and the things police are searching for.
- Write down the name and station of the officer in charge.
- Call a lawyer straight away. The search will usually continue while you make the call.
- Give your name and address, then stop talking. You do not have to answer questions about the investigation.
- Do not hand over passwords until you know your obligations. Refusing can be an offence, but only in some situations. We explain this below.
- Watch the search if police allow it, and note what they take.
- Tell police if documents contain legal advice. Communications with your lawyer are usually protected by legal professional privilege.
When Can Police Get a Search Warrant?
A magistrate or other issuing officer must approve a search warrant. Police apply on oath, and the test depends on which law they rely on.
| Type of warrant | Law | Who applies | Test |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indictable offences generally | Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) s 465 | Police officer of senior sergeant rank or above | Reasonable ground for believing things connected with, or evidence of, an indictable offence are, or will be within 72 hours, at the place |
| Drug offences | Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 (Vic) s 81 | Police officer of sergeant rank or above, or in charge of a station | Reasonable ground for believing things connected with, or evidence of, an offence under that Act are, or will be within 72 hours, at the place |
| Commonwealth offences | Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 3E | A constable, usually Australian Federal Police | Reasonable grounds for suspecting evidential material is, or will be within 72 hours, at the premises |
Note the difference. Victorian warrants require reasonable belief, whereas Commonwealth warrants require only reasonable suspicion. A Commonwealth warrant must also state its expiry time, which cannot be later than seven days after issue (s 3E(5A)).
What Police Can Do Under a Search Warrant
Search warrant powers are broad. In addition, 2022 reforms widened them further.
| Power | Source |
|---|---|
| Break, enter and search the place named in the warrant | Magistrates’ Court Act 1989 (Vic) s 78(1)(b) |
| Enter by force, at any time of day or night, within one month (drug warrants) | Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act s 81(3) |
| Search any person found on the premises (drug warrants) | Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act s 81(3)(c) |
| Break open or unlock locked containers, and move them away for up to 7 business days | Crimes Act 1958 s 465AAAA |
| Bring in technical experts and equipment | Crimes Act 1958 s 465AAAAB |
| Secure computers and phones for up to 24 hours while an expert attends | Crimes Act 1958 s 465AAAAC |
| Access and copy data on, or accessible from, a computer or phone | Crimes Act 1958 s 465AAAAF |
| Keep seized items as long as reasonably required for the investigation or prosecution | Crimes Act 1958 s 465(1A) |
| Arrest a person apparently in possession of things named in the warrant | Magistrates’ Court Act s 78(1)(b)(iii) |
Data accessible from a device can include data stored elsewhere, such as cloud accounts. As a result, a single phone can expose years of messages, photos and banking records.
Phones, Computers and Passwords
This is where people most often make costly mistakes. Some refuse when the law requires them to help. Others hand over everything when it does not.
Under search warrant law, an obligation to give passwords or other access help arises from:
| Requirement | Law | Penalty for failing to comply |
|---|---|---|
| A direction given under a warrant that authorises it | Crimes Act 1958 s 465AAA | Up to 2 years’ imprisonment (summary offence) |
| A separate Magistrates’ Court order | Crimes Act 1958 s 465AA | Up to 5 years’ imprisonment (indictable offence) |
| A Commonwealth assistance order | Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 3LA | Up to 5 years, or 10 years if the investigation concerns a serious offence |
For a Victorian offence, police must first tell you about the direction or order. They must also tell you that failing to comply is an offence (s 465AAA(4)(b); s 465AA(9)(b)). Importantly, the privilege against self-incrimination is no excuse (s 465AAA(7); s 465AA(6)).
Therefore, ask police two questions. Does the warrant authorise a direction to you? Is there a court order? If the answer is unclear, tell police you want legal advice before deciding.
Your Rights When Police Execute a Search Warrant
- Right to silence. You need not answer questions about the investigation. A court cannot draw an adverse inference from your silence (Evidence Act 2008 s 89).
- Name and address. Police can require these if they reasonably believe you committed an offence or can help with an indictable investigation. Refusing carries a fine of up to 5 penalty units (Crimes Act 1958 s 456AA). You may also ask for the officer’s name, rank and station.
- Seeing the warrant. For Commonwealth warrants, police must give the occupier a copy and identify themselves (Crimes Act 1914 s 3H). The Victorian Acts covering most searches have no equivalent rule, so ask to read the warrant anyway.
- Watching the search. Under a Commonwealth warrant, the occupier may watch, unless they impede the search (s 3P).
- Receipts. Commonwealth officers must give a receipt for anything seized or removed (s 3Q).
- A report to the court. After a Victorian search, police must lodge a report at the nearest Magistrates’ Court within 10 days (Crimes Act 1958 s 465AAC). It lists searches, arrests and things seized. Police must also tell the occupier about the report (s 465AAB).
- Inspecting the report. The occupier, owners of seized property and anyone arrested can apply to inspect it (s 465AAE). For drug warrants, the same right sits in section 81(5).
Can a Search Be Challenged?
Yes. If police obtain evidence improperly or illegally, a court may refuse to admit it. The court only admits it if the desirability of admitting it outweighs the undesirability of how police obtained it (Evidence Act 2008 s 138(1)).
The court weighs factors such as the gravity of the breach and whether it was deliberate or reckless. It also considers the importance of the evidence to the case (s 138(3)). Common issues include:
- the wrong address, or premises not covered by the warrant;
- searching for, or seizing, things outside the warrant;
- a warrant application that lacked proper grounds; and
- admissions obtained during the search without proper cautions or legal advice.
For this reason, we examine the warrant, the application and any body-worn camera footage closely. Excluding key evidence can end a prosecution.
Seized Property and Confiscation
Police can keep seized items for as long as reasonably required (Crimes Act 1958 s 465(1A)). In addition, a magistrate can direct that items be held as tainted property under the Confiscation Act 1997 (s 465(1B); Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act s 81(1A)). That can lead to forfeiture proceedings under that Act. See our page on asset restraint and confiscation.
On the other hand, the Magistrates’ Court can order property returned where that is consistent with the interests of justice (Crimes Act 1958 s 465AAD(3); Magistrates’ Court Act s 78(6)). Phones, computers and business records are often worth pursuing early.
What Happens After the Search?
A search is usually the start of an investigation, not the end. See our page on being under police investigation. Depending on what police find, you may be:
- arrested and interviewed on the day. See our guide to police interviews and your rights;
- remanded, in which case a bail application becomes urgent;
- released pending further enquiries, sometimes for months while police analyse devices; or
- charged later by summons.
Early advice matters at every stage. Often, the decisions made in the first 48 hours determine the strength of the defence. Searches commonly lead to charges such as drug trafficking, fraud and child abuse material offences.
Why Clients Choose Us
- Trial experience in the County Court and Supreme Court, in Ballarat and in Melbourne.
- Fixed fees by stage, so you know the cost of each step in a serious matter. See our fees.
- Complete discretion. We understand what a criminal investigation means for professionals and business owners.
- Available when it happens. Raids rarely happen in office hours, so we answer early mornings and weekends.
Read the legislation: Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 (Vic) and Crimes Act 1914 (Cth).
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to let police in if they have a search warrant?
Yes. A valid search warrant authorises police to enter and search the place it names, by force if necessary. Obstructing the search is a separate offence. You can still ask to read the warrant and call a lawyer while the search continues.
Do I have to give police my phone password?
Only if a direction authorised by the warrant, or a court order, requires it. In Victoria, failing to comply carries up to 2 years’ imprisonment for a direction under section 465AAA of the Crimes Act 1958, or up to 5 years for a court order under section 465AA. Police must first tell you about the requirement. Get legal advice before deciding.
Can I call a lawyer during a police search?
Yes, and you should. Police do not usually stop the search while you call, but your lawyer can advise you about questions, passwords and privileged documents as the search happens.
Will I be arrested during the search?
Not necessarily. Police can arrest a person apparently in possession of things named in the warrant, and drug warrants allow arrest of anyone found offending. Often, however, police seize items and investigate further before deciding whether to charge.
Can I get my seized property back?
Sometimes. The Magistrates’ Court can order seized property returned where that is consistent with the interests of justice. However, items may be held as tainted property under the Confiscation Act 1997, which makes recovery harder. Early advice improves your prospects.
What if the search warrant was invalid?
Evidence obtained improperly or in breach of the law may be excluded under section 138 of the Evidence Act 2008. The court weighs the seriousness of the breach against the importance of the evidence. We review the warrant, the application and the police footage for defects.
Police Search Underway? Call Now.
Call 0493 710 531 for urgent, confidential advice. We act for private clients in serious criminal matters across Victoria.
Get in Touch
Contact us for a confidential consultation with an experienced criminal defence lawyer.
