Under police investigation, or worried you soon will be? Call 0493 710 531. We answer seven days.
Most serious criminal cases begin long before a charge. A detective calls, police seize a phone, or a colleague mentions that police interviewed them. In fact, the weeks before a charge often decide the outcome. This page explains what to do if you are under police investigation in Victoria.
McMahon Criminal Defence Lawyers advises people at the pre-charge stage across Victoria. We run trials in Ballarat and Melbourne, in both the County Court and the Supreme Court. For indictable matters, we act for private clients only.
Signs You Are Under Police Investigation
- A detective calls and asks you to “come in for a chat” or an interview.
- Police execute a search warrant at your home or business.
- Police seize your phone, computer or vehicle.
- Your employer, bank or regulator tells you police have requested information.
- Friends, colleagues or family tell you police have interviewed them about you.
- Police ask you for fingerprints or a DNA sample.
Any one of these suggests you may be under police investigation. Get advice now, before you speak to police.
Under Police Investigation: Do I Have to Attend?
Not unless you are under arrest. The custody provisions of the Crimes Act give police no power to detain a person who is not under arrest (Crimes Act 1958 s 464I). An invitation to attend an interview is just that, an invitation.
However, declining can lead police to arrest you instead. For this reason, a lawyer can often arrange a time to attend, with advice first. That is usually better than an arrest at home or at work.
Arrested While Under Police Investigation
Once police take you into custody, strict rules apply.
| Rule | Victoria | Commonwealth |
|---|---|---|
| How long police can hold you | A reasonable time, then release, bail or court (Crimes Act 1958 s 464A(1)) | Up to 4 hours for questioning (2 hours for under-18s and Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander people), extendable once by up to 8 hours by a magistrate (Crimes Act 1914 ss 23C, 23DA) |
| Caution before questions | Police must tell you that you need not say or do anything (s 464A(3)) | Police must caution you (s 23F) |
| Contacting a lawyer | Police must tell you that you can contact a lawyer and a friend or relative, and generally delay questioning to allow it (s 464C) | You can contact a lawyer and arrange for them to be present during questioning (s 23G) |
| Recording | Admissions are generally inadmissible for an indictable offence unless audio or video recorded (s 464H) | Admissions must also generally be recorded (s 23V) |
The “reasonable time” in Victoria depends on factors such as the complexity of the investigation (s 464A(4)). In practice, it is not a fixed number of hours.
Importantly, your right to silence survives all of this (s 464J). A court cannot draw an adverse inference from your silence during police questioning (Evidence Act 2008 s 89). See our detailed guide to police interviews and your rights.
Fingerprints and DNA When You Are Under Police Investigation
Police often request samples early, while you are under police investigation. Your obligations depend on the procedure.
- Fingerprints. Police can fingerprint a person aged 15 or over whom they reasonably believe committed an indictable offence. They can use reasonable force if you refuse (s 464K). Police must also tell you when the prints will be destroyed, for example if you are not charged within 6 months.
- Other forensic procedures, such as DNA samples. Police can ask, but you can decline. If you refuse, police can apply to the Magistrates’ Court for an order (s 464T). In some cases, a senior officer can authorise a non-intimate sample from an adult under arrest (s 464SA).
A request must relate to a suspected indictable offence, and the procedure must tend to confirm or disprove your involvement (s 464R). Therefore, get advice before you consent to anything.
What Not to Do While Under Police Investigation
- Do not delete messages, files or accounts. Destroying something you know is likely to be needed as evidence, to stop its use, carries up to 5 years (Crimes Act 1958 s 254). Moreover, forensic examiners often recover deleted data.
- Do not contact witnesses or complainants about the allegations. Depending on what you say, contact can amount to perverting the course of justice, which carries up to 25 years (s 320).
- Do not explain yourself to police informally. Casual conversations, texts and phone calls can become evidence.
- Do not post about the matter online, even to deny it.
How Long Can Police Take to Charge You?
For indictable offences, there is generally no time limit. A proceeding may begin at any time (Criminal Procedure Act 2009 s 7(2)). By contrast, most summary offences must be charged within 12 months (s 7(1)).
As a result, you can be under police investigation for months or even years, especially where police must analyse phones and financial records. Charges may then come by summons, or by arrest.
How Early Advice Helps If You Are Under Police Investigation
- Managing contact with police. We can speak with investigators for you and arrange any attendance.
- Interview strategy. We advise whether to answer questions, decline, or provide a written statement.
- Forensic requests. We advise whether you must comply, and on what terms.
- Preserving your evidence. CCTV gets overwritten and memories fade. We secure helpful evidence early.
- Bail readiness. If an arrest is likely, we prepare bail material in advance.
- Professional obligations. Some professions require you to report a charge. See our page on criminal charges for professionals.
- Protecting your assets. Serious investigations can lead to restraining orders over property.
In some cases, early representations can also influence whether police lay charges at all.
Why Clients Choose Us
- Trial experience in the County Court and Supreme Court, in Ballarat and in Melbourne.
- Fixed fees by stage, so you know the cost of each step in a serious matter. See our fees.
- Complete discretion. We understand what a criminal investigation means for professionals and business owners.
- Available when it happens. Arrests and raids rarely happen in office hours, so we answer early mornings and weekends.
Read the legislation: Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic) and Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). See also our overview of serious and indictable charges.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to attend a police interview if I have not been arrested?
No. Police generally have no power to hold you if you are not under arrest. However, refusing an invitation can lead to an arrest, so get advice first. A lawyer can often arrange a suitable time to attend.
How long can police hold me after an arrest in Victoria?
Only for a reasonable time. Police must then release you unconditionally, release you on bail, or bring you before a bail justice or the Magistrates’ Court. What counts as reasonable depends on factors such as the complexity of the investigation.
Can police force me to give a DNA sample?
Not without authority. You can decline a request. Police can then apply to the Magistrates’ Court for an order, and in some cases a senior officer can authorise a non-intimate sample from an adult under arrest. Fingerprints are different, as police can use reasonable force.
Is there a time limit for police to charge me?
Generally not for indictable offences, which can be charged at any time. Most summary offences must be charged within 12 months of the alleged offence.
Should I delete messages if I am under police investigation?
No. Destroying something you know is likely to be needed as evidence, to stop its use, is an offence carrying up to 5 years’ imprisonment. Deleted data is also often recoverable, and deleting it can look like consciousness of guilt.
Can a lawyer stop me being charged?
No lawyer can guarantee that. However, early advice protects you from avoidable mistakes, and in some cases representations to police can influence whether charges are laid.
Under Investigation? Get Advice Before You Speak to Police.
Call 0493 710 531 for urgent, confidential advice. Early advice protects your position before any charge is laid.
Get in Touch
Contact us for a confidential consultation with an experienced criminal defence lawyer.
