Charged with a Commonwealth drug offence, or detained at the border? Call 0493 710 531. We answer seven days.
Commonwealth drug offences are a different system from Victorian drug law. In particular, it has different police, different legislation, different quantity rules and different sentencing. In some respects, it also has different rights. Moreover, most of the serious drug cases that reach the higher courts, especially importation, are Commonwealth cases. This guide explains how that system works, in ten parts. As far as we know, it is the most detailed public resource on Commonwealth drug offences, and we keep it current against the legislation.
McMahon Criminal Defence Lawyers defends Commonwealth drug prosecutions in Ballarat and Melbourne, in both the County Court and the Supreme Court. For indictable matters, we act for private clients only, so each case gets the preparation it needs.
Commonwealth drug offences guide
When Are Drug Offences Commonwealth Offences?
Victoria Police usually charge drug offences under the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 (Vic). By contrast, the Commonwealth system applies when the Australian Federal Police (AFP) or another federal agency investigates. In practice, that happens when:
- drugs or precursors cross the border, for example by air, sea, post or cargo (Criminal Code Division 307);
- the AFP investigates a syndicate operating across states or countries;
- a case begins with Australian Border Force (ABF) or the Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission (ACIC); or
- Commonwealth telephone intercepts or controlled operations produce the evidence, even if the drugs never crossed a border.
The Commonwealth offences sit in Part 9.1 of the Criminal Code, which is the Schedule to the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth). Together, they cover trafficking, cultivation, manufacture, precursors, importation, possession and offences involving children (Divisions 302 to 310). Notably, Part 9.1 expressly allows state laws to operate alongside it (s 300.4). As a result, prosecutors sometimes have a choice of regime, and that choice can change the outcome.
Commonwealth and Victorian Drug Law Compared
| Feature | Commonwealth | Victoria |
|---|---|---|
| Legislation | Criminal Code Part 9.1 | Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 |
| Investigators | AFP, ABF, ACIC | Victoria Police |
| Prosecutor | Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions | Victorian OPP or police prosecutors |
| Quantity levels | Trafficable, marketable, commercial | Traffickable, commercial, large commercial |
| How quantity is measured | Pure drug, unless a mixture quantity is listed (s 312.1) | Mixture or pure, whichever threshold is met |
| Top penalty | Life imprisonment or 7,500 penalty units, or both | Life imprisonment and 5,000 penalty units |
| Standard sentences | None | Yes, for large commercial trafficking |
| Mandatory custody categories | None | Category 1 and 2 offences |
| Jury verdicts | Must be unanimous (Constitution s 80) | Majority verdicts allowed for most offences |
| Parole decision | Commonwealth Attorney-General (Crimes Act 1914 s 19AL) | Adult Parole Board of Victoria |
The Main Commonwealth Drug Offences
| Offence | Division | Maximum penalties by quantity |
|---|---|---|
| Importing or exporting border controlled drugs | 307 | Life (commercial), 25 years (marketable), 10 years (any quantity) |
| Trafficking controlled drugs | 302 | Life, 25 years, 10 years |
| Commercial cultivation of controlled plants | 303 | Life, 25 years, 10 years |
| Commercial manufacture of controlled drugs | 305 | Life, 25 years, 10 years |
| Pre-trafficking in precursors | 306 | 25 years, 15 years, 7 years |
| Possessing unlawfully imported drugs | 307, Subdivision B | Life, 25 years, 2 years |
| Possessing controlled drugs | 308 | 2 years |
| Supplying or procuring children | 309 | Up to life |
Each offence has its own page in this guide, together with the exact section numbers and elements. Start with Drug Importation if your case involves the border, or Trafficking, Manufacture and Cultivation if it does not.
Three Features That Shape Every Commonwealth Drug Case
1. Fault elements come from Chapter 2 of the Code
Under the Code, each physical element of an offence has its own mental element. For most drug offences, the prosecution must prove you intended the conduct, such as importing, and were reckless as to whether the substance was a controlled or border controlled drug (ss 5.6, 302.2(2), 307.1(2)). In short, recklessness means you were aware of a substantial risk and it was unjustifiable to take it (s 5.4). However, quantity usually attracts absolute liability, so the prosecution need not prove you knew how much there was (s 307.1(3)). See Defences and Fault Elements.
2. Quantity drives the maximum penalty
Whether a case is a 10-year, 25-year or life matter depends on the quantity of pure drug, although there are exceptions for mixtures. The thresholds sit in the Criminal Code Regulations 2019. In addition, the prosecution can combine parcels, and even prove quantity by showing an ongoing business of trafficking or importing (Division 311). See Drug Quantities.
3. Federal sentencing law applies to Commonwealth drug offences
Sentencing follows Part IB of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), not the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic). Consequently, there are no standard sentences and no mandatory custody categories. Instead, the court must impose a sentence “of a severity appropriate in all the circumstances” (s 16A(1)), weighing the listed factors in s 16A(2). Importantly, the High Court has repeatedly held that weight is not the chief factor, and that the offender’s role and knowledge matter (Wong v The Queen [2001] HCA 64; The Queen v Pham [2015] HCA 39). See Sentencing.
Which Court Hears Commonwealth Drug Offences?
State courts try Commonwealth offences, applying state procedure (Judiciary Act 1903 s 68). In Victoria, that means the Magistrates’ Court for committal, then the County Court or Supreme Court for trial. Offences carrying 10 years or less can go to a summary hearing if both sides consent. However, the Magistrates’ Court can then impose no more than 2 years’ imprisonment (Crimes Act 1914 s 4J).
One difference matters at trial. For a Commonwealth offence tried on indictment, the jury’s verdict must be unanimous, unlike most Victorian trials. The High Court held in Cheatle v The Queen (1993) 177 CLR 541 that section 80 of the Constitution requires it. Therefore, Victoria’s majority verdict rules do not apply.
What Happens at the Start of a Commonwealth Drug Case
- At the airport or port. ABF officers can detain and search a person they reasonably suspect of carrying prohibited goods, including internal searches under court order (Customs Act 1901 Part XII, Division 1B). See Drug Importation.
- Arrest and interview. After arrest, the AFP can question you for up to 4 hours, extendable once by up to 8 hours by a magistrate (Crimes Act 1914 ss 23C, 23DA). Importantly, you can have a lawyer present (s 23G). See Federal Investigations.
- Bail. Victorian bail law applies. However, commercial quantity importation and trafficking are Schedule 1 offences, requiring exceptional circumstances (Bail Act 1977 (Vic) Sch 1, items 8 and 9). See Bail and Confiscation.
- Property. Meanwhile, the AFP can seek restraining orders under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (Cth), often early. See Bail and Confiscation.
How We Defend Commonwealth Drug Offences
- Test the fault element. Did the prosecution prove intention to import and recklessness as to the drug? Often, these cases turn on what the accused knew, and on the directions given to the jury.
- Test the quantity. Purity analysis, sampling and the mixture rules can move a case from one penalty band to another, so we examine them closely.
- Test the investigation. Controlled operations, intercepts and device access all require authority. As a result, defects can lead to exclusion of evidence.
- Prepare for sentence from day one. Role, knowledge, co-operation and personal circumstances all carry weight under s 16A, so we build that material early.
- Protect bail and property at the same time as the criminal case.
Why Clients Choose Us for Commonwealth Drug Cases
- Federal experience. We defend Commonwealth drug prosecutions, including importation, in the County Court and Supreme Court, in Ballarat and Melbourne.
- Specialist counsel. Where a case calls for it, we brief barristers who appear regularly in federal drug trials.
- Fixed fees by stage, so you know the cost of each step. See our fees.
- Private clients only for indictable matters, which means your case gets the preparation it needs.
- Available when it happens. Airport detentions and AFP raids rarely happen in office hours. We answer seven days.
Reviewed against the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), Compilation No. 174 (30 June 2026), the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), Compilation No. 167, and the Criminal Code Regulations 2019, Compilation No. 6. Last reviewed November 2026.
Read the legislation: Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) and Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). See also our Victorian drug offences and drug trafficking pages.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a Commonwealth and a state drug charge?
Commonwealth charges come under the Criminal Code and are usually investigated by the AFP or Border Force. They have different quantity thresholds, generally measured as pure drug, different maximum penalties, and federal sentencing rules under the Crimes Act 1914. State charges come under Victorian legislation and are investigated by Victoria Police.
Who prosecutes Commonwealth drug offences in Victoria?
The Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. The case is heard in Victorian courts, applying Victorian procedure, but the law of the offence and the sentencing law are federal.
Are Commonwealth drug penalties higher than Victorian penalties?
The maximums are broadly similar at the top, with life imprisonment for commercial quantities under both systems. However, the thresholds differ, Commonwealth quantities are generally measured as pure drug, and Victoria has standard sentences and mandatory custody categories that the Commonwealth does not.
Can a Commonwealth drug charge be heard in the Magistrates’ Court?
Yes, if the maximum penalty is 10 years or less and both the prosecutor and the accused consent. The Magistrates’ Court can then impose at most 2 years’ imprisonment. Commercial and marketable quantity offences must go to a higher court.
Does a Commonwealth drug trial need a unanimous jury?
Yes. Section 80 of the Constitution requires a unanimous verdict for a Commonwealth offence tried on indictment, as the High Court held in Cheatle v The Queen. Victorian majority verdict rules do not apply.
Who decides parole for a Commonwealth drug sentence?
The Commonwealth Attorney-General, under section 19AL of the Crimes Act 1914, not the Adult Parole Board of Victoria. The court fixes the non-parole period at sentence.
Facing a Federal Drug Charge? Call Now.
Call 0493 710 531 for urgent, confidential advice. We defend Commonwealth drug prosecutions in the County and Supreme Courts.
Get in Touch
Contact us for a confidential consultation with an experienced criminal defence lawyer.
