Facing sentencing for Commonwealth drug offences? Call 0493 710 531. We answer seven days.
Sentencing for Commonwealth drug offences follows federal law, not the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic). That changes a great deal. For instance, there are no standard sentences and no mandatory custody categories. Non-parole periods work differently, Canberra decides parole, and the High Court has set the principles for weighing quantity and role. This page explains the system and how we prepare a plea. It is part of our Commonwealth Drug Offences guide.
McMahon Criminal Defence Lawyers appears in Commonwealth drug sentences in Ballarat and Melbourne, in both the County Court and the Supreme Court.
Commonwealth drug offences guide
Sentencing for Commonwealth Drug Offences: Part IB of the Crimes Act 1914
State sentencing law applies to federal offenders only where Commonwealth law is silent (Judiciary Act 1903 s 68). For sentencing, however, Part IB of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) covers the field. Its central command is s 16A(1): the court must impose a sentence “of a severity appropriate in all the circumstances of the offence”.
Section 16A(2) then lists the matters the court must take into account, so far as they are relevant and known. For drug offences, in particular, the most important are:
| Factor | Section | Why it matters in drug cases |
|---|---|---|
| Nature and circumstances of the offence | s 16A(2)(a) | Quantity, purity, sophistication, duration and your role |
| Course of conduct | s 16A(2)(c) | Repeated dealing or importing is treated more seriously |
| Contrition | s 16A(2)(f) | Genuine remorse, demonstrated by conduct |
| Guilty plea, and its timing and benefit | s 16A(2)(g) | An early plea earns a larger discount |
| Co-operation with law enforcement | s 16A(2)(h) | Assistance in this or other investigations can substantially reduce the sentence |
| Deterrence, personal and general | s 16A(2)(j), (ja) | General deterrence weighs heavily in drug cases |
| Adequate punishment | s 16A(2)(k) | Proportionality to the offending |
| Character, antecedents, age, means and physical or mental condition | s 16A(2)(m) | Prior history, health and any mental impairment |
| Prospects of rehabilitation | s 16A(2)(n) | Treatment, employment, support and insight |
| Effect on family and dependants | s 16A(2)(p) | Especially relevant to carers |
In addition, a court must not impose imprisonment unless satisfied that no other sentence is appropriate (s 17A(1)). For serious drug offences, however, imprisonment is almost always the outcome.
What the High Court Has Said About Sentencing for Commonwealth Drug Offences
Three High Court decisions shape every Commonwealth drug sentence, as follows.
- Wong v The Queen [2001] HCA 64. The Court struck down a New South Wales guideline that fixed sentence ranges by weight of heroin. Weight has statutory significance through the maximum penalties, but treating it as the chief factor is an error of principle (at [70] to [73]). Moreover, many offenders do not know the quantity, so the court may need to focus on knowledge and reward instead (at [68] to [69]).
- Hili v The Queen [2010] HCA 45. There is no norm or presumptive ratio between the non-parole period and the head sentence for federal offenders (at [13], [44]). Consistency means applying the same principles, not reaching the same numbers (at [48] to [49]).
- The Queen v Pham [2015] HCA 39. Federal sentencing must be consistent across Australia, so courts must consider sentencing practice nationwide, not just in their own state (at [18] to [28]). Labelling an offender a “courier” must not obscure what they actually did, and knowledge and reward matter (at [34] to [35]). Treating quantity as the only variable for couriers is an error (at [37]).
These decisions matter in practice. Above all, they allow a sentencing judge to distinguish between offenders in the same importation, and they prevent a mechanical approach based on weight. Consequently, the evidence we assemble about your role, knowledge and reward can change the result.
Role and Knowledge in Sentencing for Commonwealth Drug Offences
In The Queen v Olbrich [1999] HCA 54, the High Court held that labels such as “courier” and “principal” are only useful shorthand, and must not obscure the assessment of what the offender did (at [19]). The Court also settled who proves what at sentence. The prosecution must prove facts adverse to you beyond reasonable doubt. By contrast, you need only prove facts in your favour on the balance of probabilities, but you must raise them (at [25] to [27]).
Therefore, a plea hearing is not a formality. If you played a limited role, had limited knowledge or received a modest reward, we must put that evidence before the court properly.
Non-Parole Periods and Recognizance Release
| Sentence | What the court must do | Law |
|---|---|---|
| Federal sentences totalling more than 3 years, or life | Fix a single non-parole period, unless it decides one is not appropriate and gives reasons | s 19AB |
| Federal sentences totalling 3 years or less | Make a recognizance release order, not a non-parole period | s 19AC |
A recognizance release order releases the offender after a set period, on conditions and security. Unlike Victoria, moreover, there is no rule of thumb for the proportion of the sentence an offender serves before release (Hili at [44]). Instead, the court applies the same principles that govern the head sentence itself.
The Commonwealth Attorney-General decides parole for a federal sentence, and must make or refuse a parole order before the non-parole period ends (s 19AL). The Adult Parole Board of Victoria has no role.
Co-operation With Authorities
Co-operation is one of the most powerful mitigating factors in a Commonwealth drug case. Past co-operation counts under s 16A(2)(h). Similarly, an undertaking to co-operate in future proceedings can also reduce the sentence or the non-parole period, in which case the court must state the sentence it would otherwise have imposed (s 16AC(1) to (2)). However, if you later refuse to co-operate without reasonable excuse, the Director of Public Prosecutions can appeal against the reduced sentence (s 16AC(3)).
Co-operation decisions carry risk, both legal and personal. Consequently, they require careful, confidential advice.
Other Options in Sentencing for Commonwealth Drug Offences
- Conditional release without conviction or sentence (s 20). For less serious offences, for example, the court can release you on a good behaviour recognizance of up to 5 years.
- State sentencing options (s 20AB). A court can use Victorian sentencing orders, such as community correction orders, for federal offenders where the Act allows.
- Summary disposal (s 4J). For offences carrying 10 years or less, heard summarily with consent, the Magistrates’ Court can only impose no more than 2 years’ imprisonment.
Sentencing for Commonwealth Drug Offences and Victorian Sentencing Compared
| Feature | Commonwealth | Victoria |
|---|---|---|
| Governing law | Crimes Act 1914 Part IB | Sentencing Act 1991 |
| Standard sentences | None | 16 years for large commercial trafficking |
| Mandatory custodial orders | None | Category 1 and 2 drug offences |
| Non-parole period | Required over 3 years; no fixed ratio | Required for 2 years or more, discretionary from 1 to 2 years (Sentencing Act 1991 s 11) |
| Sentences of 3 years or less | Recognizance release order instead of a non-parole period | Non-parole period rules above apply |
| Parole authority | Commonwealth Attorney-General | Adult Parole Board of Victoria |
| Consistency | National | Victorian practice |
Confiscation and Other Consequences
A sentence is rarely the only consequence. For instance, the AFP can pursue forfeiture and pecuniary penalty orders under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (Cth). In addition, restrained property passes to the Commonwealth automatically 6 months after conviction for a serious offence, unless a court excludes it (s 92). See Bail and Confiscation. Likewise, professionals face regulatory consequences. See our page on criminal charges for professionals.
How We Prepare a Plea in Sentencing for Commonwealth Drug Offences
- Agree the facts. The agreed summary defines your role and knowledge. Accordingly, we negotiate it carefully.
- Build the s 16A material. Reports, references, treatment evidence and employment history, each addressed to a listed factor.
- Research national practice. Because consistency is national, we draw on comparable decisions from every state, not only Victoria.
- Advise on co-operation. Where it is an option, we explain the benefits and the risks.
- Address release. Finally, we make submissions on the non-parole period or recognizance release order, not just the head sentence.
For the offences themselves, see Drug Importation and Trafficking, Manufacture and Cultivation. For appeals against a federal sentence, see our criminal appeals page.
Why Clients Choose Us for Commonwealth Drug Cases
- Federal experience. We defend Commonwealth drug prosecutions, including importation, in the County Court and Supreme Court, in Ballarat and Melbourne.
- Specialist counsel. Where a case calls for it, we brief barristers who appear regularly in federal drug trials.
- Fixed fees by stage, so you know the cost of each step. See our fees.
- Private clients only for indictable matters, which means your case gets the preparation it needs.
- Available when it happens. Airport detentions and AFP raids rarely happen in office hours. We answer seven days.
Reviewed against the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), Compilation No. 174 (30 June 2026), the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), Compilation No. 167, and the Criminal Code Regulations 2019, Compilation No. 6. Last reviewed November 2026.
Read the legislation: Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). Read the judgments: Wong v The Queen [2001] HCA 64, Hili v The Queen [2010] HCA 45 and The Queen v Pham [2015] HCA 39.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Victorian Sentencing Act apply to Commonwealth drug offences?
Only where Commonwealth law is silent. Part IB of the Crimes Act 1914 governs the sentencing of federal offenders, including the factors the court must consider, non-parole periods and release orders.
Are there standard sentences in sentencing for Commonwealth drug offences?
No. Victoria’s standard sentence scheme and its mandatory custody categories do not apply to federal offences. The court must impose a sentence of a severity appropriate in all the circumstances under section 16A.
How is the non-parole period set for a federal drug sentence?
For sentences over 3 years, the court must fix a single non-parole period unless it decides one is not appropriate. The High Court held in Hili v The Queen that there is no presumptive ratio between the non-parole period and the head sentence.
Who grants parole for a Commonwealth sentence?
The Commonwealth Attorney-General, under section 19AL of the Crimes Act 1914. The Attorney-General must make or refuse a parole order before the non-parole period ends.
How much does co-operation reduce a Commonwealth drug sentence?
There is no fixed discount. Past co-operation is a factor under section 16A(2)(h), and an undertaking to co-operate can reduce the sentence or non-parole period under section 16AC. The court must state the sentence it would otherwise have imposed.
Is quantity the main factor in sentencing for Commonwealth drug offences?
No. The High Court held in Wong v The Queen and The Queen v Pham that weight is relevant but not the chief factor. Your role, knowledge, reward and all the section 16A matters must be weighed.
Facing a Federal Sentence? Preparation Matters.
Call 0493 710 531 for confidential advice. We prepare Commonwealth pleas with national sentencing practice in view.
Get in Touch
Contact us for a confidential consultation with an experienced criminal defence lawyer.
