Serious & Indictable Offences Lawyer Victoria


Serious indictable offence lawyer Victoria

Charged with an indictable offence? Call 0493 710 531. We answer seven days.

An indictable offence is a serious criminal charge that can go to trial before a judge and jury. The stakes are high: long prison terms, confiscation of property and lasting damage to a career. This page explains how indictable offences work in Victoria, from the first hearing to trial.

McMahon Criminal Defence Lawyers defends serious and indictable charges across Victoria. We run trials in Ballarat and Melbourne, in both the County Court and the Supreme Court. For indictable matters, we act for private clients only, not on Legal Aid. As a result, your case gets the time it needs.

Summary or Indictable Offence: Why It Matters

Victorian offences are either summary or indictable. The Magistrates’ Court always hears summary offences. Indictable offences are more serious, and a jury can try them in the County Court or Supreme Court.

However, the Magistrates’ Court can still hear many indictable offences summarily. This applies to offences listed in Schedule 2 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009, and generally to offences carrying 10 years or less (s 28). Two conditions apply. First, the court must consider a summary hearing appropriate. Second, you must consent (s 29(1)).

The choice has real consequences. In a summary hearing, the Magistrates’ Court can impose no more than 2 years’ imprisonment for each indictable offence (Sentencing Act 1991 s 113). It also has a limit of 5 years for cumulative sentences (s 113B). On the other hand, a jury trial in a higher court may offer better prospects in a contested case. We advise on this decision carefully.

How an Indictable Offence Case Progresses

Stage What happens Law
Filing hearing The first hearing in the Magistrates’ Court. It occurs within 7 days of the charge if you are in custody or on bail, or 28 days if you are summonsed Criminal Procedure Act 2009 ss 101, 102
Hand-up brief Police serve the prosecution evidence, including witness statements and exhibits ss 107, 110
Committal mention and case conference The parties discuss the issues, the charges and possible resolution ss 125, 127
Committal hearing (if held) Witnesses may be cross-examined, but only with the court’s leave ss 124, 128
Committal for trial The Magistrates’ Court sends the case to the County Court or Supreme Court s 144
Indictment and pre-trial The prosecution files an indictment, and the court manages pre-trial issues s 160
Trial Generally must start within 12 months of committal, or 3 months for sexual offences, unless extended ss 211, 212

Many cases resolve before trial, through negotiation, a plea, or a summary hearing. In fact, the committal stage is often the best opportunity to narrow or withdraw charges.

2025 Committal Changes for Indictable Offences

Committal law changed in 2025, and older guidance online may now be wrong. Notably:

  • No test of evidence. A committal no longer determines whether the evidence is strong enough to support a conviction. Instead, the court must commit the accused for trial at the end of the committal (ss 97, 141).
  • No committal hearing for some charges. There is no cross-examination at committal for sexual offences, family violence offences or stalking (ss 100(1A), 123).
  • Early committal to the Supreme Court. Charges outside the County Court’s jurisdiction now go straight to the Supreme Court once police serve and file the hand-up brief (Part 4.6A).

Where cross-examination is still possible, you need the court’s leave. The court must find the questioning directly and substantially relevant to an identified issue. There must also be substantial reasons in the interests of justice (s 124(3)).

Which Court Hears an Indictable Offence?

The County Court hears most indictable offences. However, some offences are outside its jurisdiction, including treason, murder and attempted murder (County Court Act 1958 s 36A). Those charges go to the Supreme Court.

In other cases, the prosecution chooses where to file the indictment, having regard to factors such as complexity (Criminal Procedure Act s 160). The County Court sits in Ballarat and other regional centres, as well as in Melbourne.

Sentence Indications for Indictable Offences

Before trial, you can ask the judge for a sentence indication (s 207). The judge may indicate the likely type of sentence, or a maximum total effective sentence, if you plead guilty.

  • Only the accused can apply, and generally only once (s 208).
  • If you plead guilty at the first available opportunity, the court cannot impose a more severe sentence than indicated (s 209(1)).
  • The application cannot be used as evidence against you (s 209(5)).

Used well, a sentence indication gives certainty without giving anything away.

Serious Indictable Offences We Defend

Offence area Related pages
Homicide Murder and manslaughter, culpable and dangerous driving causing death
Sexual offences Sexual offences, rape and sexual assault, child sexual offences, child abuse material
Drugs Drug trafficking, drug offences
Violence Causing serious injury, robbery and armed robbery, burglary and aggravated burglary
Dishonesty Fraud and deception, theft and dishonesty
Weapons Firearms, weapons offences
Justice offences Perjury and offences against justice

Before and Beyond the Charge

Why Clients Choose Us

  • Trial experience in the County Court and Supreme Court, in Ballarat and in Melbourne.
  • Fixed fees by stage, so you know the cost of each step in a serious matter. See our fees.
  • Complete discretion. We understand what a criminal investigation means for professionals and business owners.
  • Available when it happens. Arrests and raids rarely happen in office hours, so we answer early mornings and weekends.

Read the legislation: Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic).

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a summary and an indictable offence?

Summary offences are less serious and are always heard in the Magistrates’ Court. Indictable offences are more serious and can be tried before a judge and jury in the County Court or Supreme Court, although many can also be heard summarily.

Can an indictable offence be heard in the Magistrates’ Court?

Often, yes. Many indictable offences can be heard summarily if the court considers it appropriate and the accused consents. The Magistrates’ Court can then impose up to 2 years’ imprisonment for each offence, and up to 5 years in total for cumulative sentences.

What is a committal hearing?

It is a hearing in the Magistrates’ Court where defence lawyers may cross-examine prosecution witnesses, with the court’s leave. Since 2025, committals no longer test whether the evidence could support a conviction, and some charges have no committal hearing at all.

How long does an indictable case take?

It varies, but serious cases often take a year or more. The trial generally must start within 12 months of committal, or 3 months for sexual offences, although courts can extend these periods.

Which court hears a murder charge?

The Supreme Court. Murder, attempted murder and treason are outside the County Court’s jurisdiction.

What is a sentence indication?

Before trial, the accused can ask the judge what type of sentence, or maximum total sentence, would likely follow a guilty plea. If the accused then pleads guilty at the first available opportunity, the court cannot exceed the indication.



Serious Charge? Get Experienced Trial Lawyers.

Call 0493 710 531. We defend serious and indictable charges in the County and Supreme Courts, in Ballarat and Melbourne.

Get in Touch

Contact us for a confidential consultation with an experienced criminal defence lawyer.

Name
Email
How would you like to discuss your case?
Drag & Drop Files, Choose Files to Upload You can upload up to 10 files.