Facing a Commonwealth drug charge and want to know your defences? Call 0493 710 531. We answer seven days.
Defences to Commonwealth drug charges start with the structure of the Criminal Code. Every offence breaks into physical elements, and each physical element carries its own fault element. In turn, understanding that structure shows where the prosecution’s case is weakest. This page explains the fault elements and the burdens of proof. It also covers the specific defences in Part 9.1, and the extended liability rules for conspiracy, complicity and attempt. It is part of our Commonwealth Drug Offences guide.
McMahon Criminal Defence Lawyers defends Commonwealth drug prosecutions in Ballarat and Melbourne, in both the County Court and the Supreme Court.
Commonwealth drug offences guide
Fault Elements: the Foundation of Defences to Commonwealth Drug Charges
Chapter 2 of the Code sets the general rules. In short, where an offence does not specify a fault element, intention applies to conduct, and recklessness applies to circumstances and results (s 5.6). Part 9.1 then adjusts those defaults for each offence, as the table below shows.
| Fault element | Meaning | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Intention (conduct) | You meant to engage in the conduct | s 5.2 |
| Knowledge | You were aware that a circumstance existed or would exist | s 5.3 |
| Recklessness | You were aware of a substantial risk, and taking it was unjustifiable in the circumstances known to you | s 5.4 |
| Absolute liability | No fault element, and no mistake-of-fact defence | s 6.2 |
Applied to drug offences, the pattern is consistent. First, the prosecution must prove intention as to the conduct, such as importing, trafficking or possessing. Next, it must prove recklessness as to the substance being a controlled or border controlled drug. By contrast, quantity attracts absolute liability. Proof of intention or knowledge also satisfies recklessness, so a person who knew the substance was a drug is also reckless (s 5.4(4)).
The Knowledge Defence: “I Didn’t Know”
This is the most common defence in importation and courier cases. Here, the prosecution must prove you intended to import the substance. In Smith v The Queen; The Queen v Afford [2017] HCA 19, the High Court held that a jury may infer intention where you knew or believed there was a real or significant chance the item contained a substance, and proceeded anyway (at [57] to [63]). However, the inference must be the only reasonable one, proved beyond reasonable doubt (at [61], [69]).
Therefore, the defence case addresses the circumstances the prosecution relies on, such as who arranged the travel, what the messages say, and whether any innocent explanation remains open. Equally, the jury must keep the intention and recklessness questions distinct, a point the Court stressed (at [68]). A direction that blurs them is a ground of appeal. See Drug Importation.
Mistake of Fact
Where a fault element applies, an honest mistake that negates it is a complete answer (s 9.1). For example, a person who believed a package contained documents, and had no awareness of a risk that it contained drugs, lacks both intention to import a substance and recklessness as to the drug. The jury may consider whether the belief was reasonable, but the law does not require reasonableness (s 9.1(2)).
By contrast, mistake of fact is unavailable for absolute liability elements such as quantity (s 6.2(2)). Instead, two partial defences apply:
- Mistake as to quantity (s 313.4). If you prove you mistakenly believed the quantity was smaller, and that belief would have made you guilty of a lesser offence, the jury may convict you of the lesser offence. This does not apply to Division 307 importation offences.
- Mistake as to identity of the drug (s 313.5). The same applies if you mistakenly believed the substance was a different drug carrying a lower penalty. Again, this excludes Division 307.
In both cases, notably, you bear the legal burden, on the balance of probabilities (ss 13.4, 13.5).
Who Must Prove What
The default rule is that the prosecution proves every element beyond reasonable doubt. However, the Code shifts certain burdens to the accused. Moreover, the type of burden matters.
| Burden | What it requires | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Evidential burden (s 13.3) | You must point to evidence that suggests a reasonable possibility the matter exists. The prosecution must then disprove it beyond reasonable doubt | Duress (s 10.2), conduct excused by state law (s 313.1), reasonable belief in lawful authority (s 313.2), purchaser exception (s 302.6) |
| Legal burden (s 13.4) | You must prove the matter on the balance of probabilities (s 13.5) | Rebutting the trafficable quantity presumption (s 302.5(2)), no commercial intent (s 307.2(4)), not knowing a drug was imported (s 307.5(4)), mistake as to quantity (s 313.4) |
In practice, the legal-burden defences require evidence from the defence side, often including the accused giving evidence. That decision therefore needs careful planning.
Specific Defences to Commonwealth Drug Charges in Part 9.1
- Conduct justified or excused by state law (s 313.1). Part 9.1, other than Division 307, does not apply to conduct in a state that the state’s law justifies or excuses. For example, lawful possession under a Victorian permit or prescription.
- Reasonable belief in lawful authority (s 313.2). A mistaken but reasonable belief that the conduct was lawful under Commonwealth or state law is a defence, provided the conduct would have been lawful had the belief been correct.
- No commercial intent (ss 307.2(4), 307.3(3), 307.6(4), 307.9(4)). For marketable and basic importation and possession-of-import offences, proving you neither intended, nor believed another intended, to sell any of the drug is a defence. For the basic importation offence, the 2-year offence in s 307.4 may still apply.
- Not knowing about the importation (ss 307.5(4) to 307.7(4)). A defence to possessing unlawfully imported drugs. See Possessing Imported Drugs.
- Purchaser exception (s 302.6). Finally, buying drugs does not make you an accessory to or conspirator in the seller’s trafficking.
General Defences to Commonwealth Drug Charges
- Duress (s 10.2). You reasonably believed that someone would carry out a threat unless you offended, that there was no reasonable way to make it ineffective, and that your conduct was a reasonable response. However, duress is unavailable if the threat came from someone you voluntarily associated with for the purpose of that kind of conduct (s 10.2(3)). Consequently, drug couriers who claim coercion often face that exclusion.
- Sudden or extraordinary emergency (s 10.3). Rarely relevant, although available in principle.
- Mental impairment (s 7.3). A complete defence where it applies, although with its own procedure.
Extended Liability: Conspiracy, Complicity and Attempt
Commonwealth drug prosecutions frequently charge people who never touched the drugs. In particular, four provisions make that possible.
| Provision | What it catches | Key limits |
|---|---|---|
| Conspiracy (s 11.5) | An agreement to commit an offence, where you and at least one other party intended it and someone did an overt act | Withdrawal before any overt act, plus reasonable steps to prevent the offence, is a defence (s 11.5(5)). The court may dismiss a conspiracy charge in the interests of justice (s 11.5(6)) |
| Complicity (s 11.2) | Aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring another’s offence | You must have intended to assist an offence of that type, or been reckless about the offence actually committed (s 11.2(3)). Termination plus reasonable steps to prevent it is a defence (s 11.2(4)) |
| Joint commission (s 11.2A) | An agreement to commit an offence, where an offence is committed in accordance with it or in the course of carrying it out | Each party is liable for the joint offence |
| Attempt (s 11.1) | Conduct more than merely preparatory, with intention or knowledge for every element | Impossibility is no defence (s 11.1(4)) |
Notably, an attempt requires intention or knowledge for every element, including the substance being a drug (s 11.1(3)). Consequently, recklessness is not enough on an attempt charge, which can make attempt harder to prove than the completed offence.
Challenging the Evidence
Beyond the elements, defences to Commonwealth drug charges often turn on how the evidence was obtained. Every Commonwealth drug case depends on evidence obtained under statutory powers. A court may exclude evidence that investigators obtained improperly or unlawfully, under s 138 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic), which applies in Victorian courts hearing federal matters. Common targets include:
- controlled operations that exceeded their authority or induced the offence (Crimes Act 1914 s 15HA(2)(c));
- intercept or surveillance warrants with defects;
- device access without a valid order (Crimes Act 1914 s 3LA);
- interviews conducted in breach of Part IC; and
- forensic analysis with sampling or chain-of-custody problems.
See Federal Investigations and Drug Quantities.
How We Build Defences to Commonwealth Drug Charges
- Map the elements. First, we identify the fault element for each physical element and ask what evidence proves it.
- Find the weakest link. Usually, that is intention or recklessness, or the quantity.
- Plan the burdens. Where a legal burden sits on you, we gather the evidence early, before it disappears.
- Test the investigation. We review every warrant, authority and interview.
- Keep sentence in view. If the case resolves, the work done on role and knowledge then feeds directly into mitigation. See Sentencing.
Why Clients Choose Us for Commonwealth Drug Cases
- Federal experience. We defend Commonwealth drug prosecutions, including importation, in the County Court and Supreme Court, in Ballarat and Melbourne.
- Specialist counsel. Where a case calls for it, we brief barristers who appear regularly in federal drug trials.
- Fixed fees by stage, so you know the cost of each step. See our fees.
- Private clients only for indictable matters, which means your case gets the preparation it needs.
- Available when it happens. Airport detentions and AFP raids rarely happen in office hours. We answer seven days.
Reviewed against the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), Compilation No. 174 (30 June 2026), the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), Compilation No. 167, and the Criminal Code Regulations 2019, Compilation No. 6. Last reviewed November 2026.
Read the legislation: Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth). Read the judgment: Smith v The Queen; The Queen v Afford [2017] HCA 19.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does recklessness mean in defences to Commonwealth drug charges?
Under section 5.4 of the Criminal Code, you were aware of a substantial risk that the substance was a controlled or border controlled drug, and it was unjustifiable to take that risk in the circumstances known to you. Proof of knowledge or intention also satisfies recklessness.
Is ‘I didn’t know’ a defence to drug importation?
It can be. The prosecution must prove you intended to import the substance. If you had no awareness of a real chance that the item contained a substance, you lack that intention. However, the High Court has held that a jury may infer intention from awareness of a real or significant chance, where you went ahead anyway.
Is mistake about quantity one of the defences to Commonwealth drug charges?
For trafficking, manufacture and cultivation, yes, as a partial defence under section 313.4. If you prove the mistake, you may be convicted of a lesser offence. For importation offences under Division 307, no such defence exists.
What is the difference between an evidential burden and a legal burden?
An evidential burden only requires you to point to evidence raising a reasonable possibility, after which the prosecution must disprove it beyond reasonable doubt. A legal burden requires you to prove the matter on the balance of probabilities.
Is duress one of the defences to Commonwealth drug charges for a courier?
It can be, but it is limited. You must have reasonably believed a threat would be carried out, with no reasonable way to avoid it, and your response must have been reasonable. It is unavailable if the threat came from people you voluntarily associated with for that kind of conduct.
Can I be convicted of conspiracy if the drugs never arrived?
Yes. Conspiracy requires an agreement, an intention that the offence be committed, and an overt act by any party. Impossibility is no defence. Withdrawing before any overt act and taking reasonable steps to prevent the offence is a defence.
Every Element Can Be Tested. Call Now.
Call 0493 710 531 for confidential advice. We map every element of a Commonwealth drug charge and find where the case is weakest.
Get in Touch
Contact us for a confidential consultation with an experienced criminal defence lawyer.
